DieselDialogue
Write a review

What reviewers mention

Counted from the words and stars in the reviews below

Reviewers most often mention customer service, delivery and returns & refunds. Reviews about customer service and returns & refunds are more critical. Based on 47 reviews.

  • Customer service28 reviews, average 1.4 out of 5
  • Delivery24 reviews, average 1.5 out of 5
  • Returns & refunds21 reviews, average 1.4 out of 5
  • Website & ordering19 reviews, average 1.6 out of 5
  • Communication18 reviews, average 1.6 out of 5
  • Prices12 reviews, average 2.2 out of 5

Reviews47

kathpan

Purchased a set of front floor mats for my son's 2002 Nissan Pathfinder as a Christmas gift. The fit was TERRIBLE. Custom Fit??? No way. Should have bought the generics at Walmart. Sad, because we really do try to buy products made in the USA. Won't be recommending these to our friends.

soccerdoc

I ordered a cargo mat and did receive the product on the date specified. I did not receive an email order confirmation until I emailed and called customer service requesting one. Otherwise there were no problems. Product fit great. I have had floor mats and cargo mat in my other vehicle for 9 years and they have worked great in collecting rain and snow without draining or overflow onto floor

t81will

I would like everyone to beware of this company! I ordered "digital" floor mats for my vehicle nearly a month ago. Once I received them the rear mats obviously did not fit, I contacted the company and they asked me to take pictures to prove this ill fit and for them to show them to engineering. I was then told, "that's just how they're going to fit." They were supposed to send a return label, but when I didn't receive that, I called and they blamed it on the USPS frequently losing their outgoing mail. They then set up a Fedex pick up at my home, which took another phone call because it didn't happen, but of course that was Fedex's fault. The second try they picked it up. MacNeil received the item back to them on 11/8, I called on 11/10 and asked about my refund I was told that it takes 3-5days. Today is 11/16 I still do not have the refund. I called and spoke w/a manager who blamed it on the employee for sending it to wrong department, and informed me that just because there are multiple models of my vehile, ALL of the floors are exactly the same! I assured him they are not. There is a difference in the floor of the $20,000 and the $50,000 model. At no time have they offered to refund the entire amount of my purchase, considering the trouble they have put me through. I am filing a complaint w/the BBB and if I do not see something happening w/in the next 5days, I will be seeking legal action. This company needs to learn to stand behind their product.

pcosco

DO NOT SHOP HERE! We bought custom floor mats for our vehicle, which were supposed to digitally fit our new car. They were quite expensive, and may have been worth it if they fit, but the did not!!! We have attempted to contact this company many times, and have emailed them with photos to prove that they did not fit... but noone ever got back to us and now we are stuck with these worthless floor mats. We wish we would have purchased them somewhere else. They have no problem taking your order and promise their guarantee but when you wish to call them up on it, they are no where to be found. I never write negative reviews about any company but in this case, with such POOR CUSTOMER SERVICE we had no choice but to write this review in the hope that no one else will have to go through what we went through. I REPEAT--- DO NOT PLACE AN ORDER WITH THIS COMPANY!

JohnDIV

Will not shop there again. Ordered digital fit mats for my F-250 because they are supposed to be a precise fit. The mats gapped at the transmission hump and kick panels. I contacted MacNeil and left a message requesting a return authorization number. Guess what? NO RESPONSE. So I had to modify the mats to eliminate the poor fit. Sure hope they last. Finally, their idea of tan is actually a dark cocoa color.

kibbynet

I became concerned after reading reviews of MacNeil's online store/service after already ordering mats for my Tacoma. So, I was relieved when the entire order arrived by FedEx 4 days later. The mats fit perfectly and the grey color works with my truck and matched the color shown on the store's web site. My previously purchased WeatherTech cargo mat for my 1997 Explorer survived 14 years of use/abuse. The mats aren't cheap, but I expect them to last. Shipping was a little expensive. Overall, I'm very happy with this purchase.

PaulJE

I ordered mats for my car and they came 1 week apart from each other. When the back seat mats came in they did not fit over the back seat hump of my car due to fixed cup holders on the back of the center console. I called customer service and they said that they will not take it back and modify the mat to fit the back seat, that I would have to cut it out myself. Not woth the money and the hassle from these guys. I would look else where.

Jschonhoff

Worst customer service I have ever experienced. Over 5 weeks since I orderd my floor mats and I still only have the front row. First they sent me someone elses order completely and then when they reshipped they only sent front row - 2nd and 3rd rows were not shipped. Since then I have spent 6 hours on the phone trying to get them to ship the rest of my order. 4 different people promised me they would take care of it and get them shipped right away with zero results. it is amazing this company can stay in business.

SerafinodePascualo

Weather Tech from Mac Neil Automotive has some of the worst service I have ever dealt with. With emails not answered and over 40 minutes spent waiting on the phone communication seems almost non-existent. The product can be good, if you get the correct one. The product descriptions on the website are not clear and do not correctly represent the cars. Suggestion, do not purchase from them.

tbrady

WARNING - DO NOT ORDER FROM MACNEIL! The worst customer service I have ever experienced. They do not respond to e-mails and they will not answer the phone when you call their customer service number. On 12/17 I placed my order. When I determined that they would not arrive in time for Christmas, despite what I had been told, I e-mailed to change my shipping address. On 12/21 they finally returned my e-mail saying the ship address had been updated. It took over 3 weeks for the order to be filled and then they shipped to the wrong address! STAY AWAY - YOU HAVE BEEN WARNED!

car_shopper

The worst !!!!!! Stay away!!!! 2 hour on hold everytime you call their customer service! No refund, even after I got and RMA and send back the brand new item. Not responding to emails. This 2010!!!! How do they stay in bsns?

tmays4444

Stay away! Terrible customer service. They sent me wroong floor mats. I waited for over an hour on customer service. Then they told me I had to pay for shipping even though they sent me the wrong mats. REALLY! REALLY BAD. On top of the that the mats were O.K. to say the best. Not worth the frustration. Get some other mats for 1/4 of the cost and save you the headache.

medicontruck

STAY AWAY!!!!!!! Ordered mats in November. Still not here. It is impossible to contact anyone there. Tried for days. AWEFUL service. Worst online experience Ive had.

hootond

I ordered a new stone and bug screen for my new F-150. It arrived okay and on time. I had a question about the installation instructions and called their 800#. On three separate occasions over a 2-day period I was told each time that I would have over one-hour in waiting time before I could speak to a support person. Absolutely unacceptable service!

paulljaniking

Ordered digital fit front liners for my Ford Focus after xmas 2010 and received them in a week. The liners fit perfectly, are heavily constructed and look great. They cover the floor area so much that there isn't any carpet to vacuum. The $100 price is expensive but worth it. You get what you pay for!

SLC_Raider

I ordered floor mats and cargo liner for my 2004 Audi in November, 3 weeks later I finally received my order to find that the floor mats were generic "cut to fit" rubber mats (same ones I could have purchased at PEP Boys at 1/2 the cost). I called the company and informed them that I would not be paying for the order as it was not what I believed I had ordered. The company said they would send me a return shipping label and refund me in full when they received the returned merchandise. I shipped them back the order, a week after they received the returned merchandise they still had not refunded my money. I then called their customer service department and the person confirmed they had received the returned order and promised that they would be issuing a refund to my credit card that day. A week later still no refund. Then yesterday I checked my credit card account to find that they had hit me with an additional $244.90 charge. I immediately called my credit card company and had them process a charge back for the unauthorized $244.90 charge. I then sent an email to the customer service rep who had promised I would get a refund informing them that I have initiated a charge back on the initial purchase amount since they did not refund my money as promised. Needless to say, this is one company that I will never do business with again.

Tuckersky

I purchased two sets of front mats for a 2010 Toyota Sienna and a 2008 Nissan Sentra. The Sienna's mats fit perfectly but the Sentra's are a terrible fit. Read the product description, while some mats are custom fit others are only close. Call and make sure your order is a custom fit, if not you'd make out much better at a local auto store for about half the price. For the price charged this mats should fit well. I will either have to pay return shipping or trim my mat. Also, the installation instructions say not to use the mat if the little hook that keeps the driver side mat from sliding forward doesn't hook into the mat. My hook is about 7 inches away from the hole!! The mat itself doesn't even reach the hook. The Sentra mats are a huge dissapointment!

djr136

Ordered a Weathertech cargo liner for my 2009 Lincoln Navigator.The product arrived in a timely manner,albeit in chocolate brown instead of tan as I had requested.Brought this up with McNeil Automotive,the customer service rep told me I could return the product but that I would be responsible for shipping, which I did not feel was fair.Long story short - at McNeil Automotive brown is tan and if you don't like it too bad.

jcwolff

Ordered a set of front and rear FloorLiner™ DigitalFit for my 2010 Prius after reading the following shipping info on WeatherTec website (USA, "Please allow 3 to 7 business days for manufacturing and up to 5 business days for FedEx ground shipping (unless you chose express shipping) to deliver your package to your door from our Kansas manufacturing facility." After waiting the listed time on the website I emailed WeatherTech for an estimated ship date and was told they would ship by the end of last week 3-26-10 low-an-behold as of Monday, March 29th still no ship date. BTW they will attempt to explanation their sllllllow shipping by suggesting they create floor mats one set at a time. So I emailed WeatherTech to get an estimated shipping date twice with no response. If you don't mind waiting and being ignored then give this Co. a try. But be forewarned, they take forever to ship and will ignore you when you contact them for an update or explanation. Finally after 15 business days and 3 emails later (the last 2 have been ignored) my floor mats arrived. From the one and only response received from WeatherTech/MacMeil Your order should be shipping out of the warehouse by the end of the week. The DigitalFit FloorLiners are a made to order product so they take a little longer to get to the customer. We appreciate your patience! Feel free to contact me with any further questions or comments, and thank you once again for your business! (NOTE I DID on TWO OCCASIONS WITH NO RESPONSE!!!) Kelly Martin ****@****

mat_less

I ordered a set of floor mats for my 2010 GMC Acadia. The website says the product ships in 3-5 business days. A classic example of over promising and under delivering!!! After 13 business days the mats still haven't shipped. I tried to call on the status at 3pm Monday (their time) but was on hold of over 20 minutes. No one answered the customer service number so I guess I would rate their customer service as non-existent.

About MacNeil Automotive

Listed
Listed on DieselDialogue since , 47 reviews

Similar companies in Auto & Car Service