DieselDialogue, home
Write a review

What reviewers mention

Counted from the words and stars in the reviews below

Reviewers most often mention customer service, delivery and returns & refunds. Reviews about customer service and delivery are more critical. Based on 47 reviews.

  • Customer service27 reviews, average 1.4 out of 5
  • Delivery23 reviews, average 1.4 out of 5
  • Returns & refunds20 reviews, average 1.4 out of 5
  • Website & ordering19 reviews, average 1.6 out of 5
  • Communication17 reviews, average 1.6 out of 5
  • Prices11 reviews, average 2.2 out of 5

2-star reviews7

bwb..

Just ordered "custom" front rubber mats for my 2003 Sequoia. they fit very poorly. I have no idea how they consider it a custom fit as they fit no better than if I went to Walmart or such. The quality lags behind the OEM by far. AND their return policy doesn't pay for returns, even though it is a improper fit. AND the customer service rep. hung up on me after giving me the RA number.

BadBuster

We had rear cargo liner for a 2000 Lexus RX that fit quite well and has been great for the last 10+ years. So we ordered All-Weather Floor Mats for a very clean 2001 Nissan Pathfinder in tan. Quality good; color as shown on website; the fitment is not consistent with the contours of the floor. I could have picked some up at the local auto parts, and been on par with what I received from MacNeil. Really! Save your $$ and shop at the local auto parts store. Not impressed and won't even bother trying to get a refund based on what I've read from others on this site, about the poor customer service. Hope this helps!

JohnFB

Ordered digital fit mats for my 2010 Tacoma because they are supposed to be a precise fit. The mats gapped at the transmission hump and kick panels - loosely fit. One inch gap at the kick panels both left and right sides. Sure do not fit my Tacoma as nicely as the WeatherTech online website photo shows. Quality of the material the mats are made of so far is very good. Other than a POOR FIT the mats serve their purpose very well.

jstbad

Rear mat required some cutting/modification by purchaser. Before my purchase I e-mailed their customer service twice asking specifically about this since my truck configuration was not specifically covered in their website. I never received a response to my question. I finally called and spoke to a customer service representative and asked specifically about the rear mat. For the F-150 there is an additional note on their website regarding an optional subwoofer, my truck does not have that but does have a factory installed 700w amplifier under the right rear passenger seat. This is where the cutting is apparently necessary. Their website does not state this at all however an information sheet I received in the box with the mats does mention "Some rear WeatherTech All-Weather mats are designed to be trimmed." The following is from their website under the 'Description' tab: "The WeatherTech® FloorLiner™DigitalFit®accurately and completely lines the interior carpet giving "absolute interior protection™"! Digital laser measurements of interior surfaces offer a consistently perfect fit!" And this is from the same tab under the heading "Over the Hump Floor Liner: Rear FloorLiner™DigitalFit® incorporates many of the same design features as the front FloorLiner™ DigitalFit®." Nowhere did I see anything about trimming/cutting. Additionally, the ‘Installation’ tab makes no mention of any possible trimming. For me, perfect fit does not mean trimming required. I'm not the brightest bulb in the box nor do I have the steady hands of a neurosurgeon so if I make a mistake and cut it wrong it's on me. FYI, Sheila from customer service did convince management to send me a shipping label to return the rear mat at no cost to me: Thank you Sheila.

PaulJE

I ordered mats for my car and they came 1 week apart from each other. When the back seat mats came in they did not fit over the back seat hump of my car due to fixed cup holders on the back of the center console. I called customer service and they said that they will not take it back and modify the mat to fit the back seat, that I would have to cut it out myself. Not woth the money and the hassle from these guys. I would look else where.

jcwolff

Ordered a set of front and rear FloorLiner™ DigitalFit for my 2010 Prius after reading the following shipping info on WeatherTec website (USA, "Please allow 3 to 7 business days for manufacturing and up to 5 business days for FedEx ground shipping (unless you chose express shipping) to deliver your package to your door from our Kansas manufacturing facility." After waiting the listed time on the website I emailed WeatherTech for an estimated ship date and was told they would ship by the end of last week 3-26-10 low-an-behold as of Monday, March 29th still no ship date. BTW they will attempt to explanation their sllllllow shipping by suggesting they create floor mats one set at a time. So I emailed WeatherTech to get an estimated shipping date twice with no response. If you don't mind waiting and being ignored then give this Co. a try. But be forewarned, they take forever to ship and will ignore you when you contact them for an update or explanation. Finally after 15 business days and 3 emails later (the last 2 have been ignored) my floor mats arrived. From the one and only response received from WeatherTech/MacMeil Your order should be shipping out of the warehouse by the end of the week. The DigitalFit FloorLiners are a made to order product so they take a little longer to get to the customer. We appreciate your patience! Feel free to contact me with any further questions or comments, and thank you once again for your business! (NOTE I DID on TWO OCCASIONS WITH NO RESPONSE!!!) Kelly Martin ****@****

Sharkin

Good automotive products, although quite expensive. It took three different products to properly fit my Ford F-150 for its side window deflectors. The moonroof deflector couldn't be installed. They made me pay the return shipping on that. Total out of pocket was $32, which included shipping it back and the shipping I paid to have it sent to me. Still haven't received a credit yet. Other suppliers offer similar merchandise at much lower prices.

Show all reviews

About MacNeil Automotive

Listed
Listed on DieselDialogue since , 47 reviews

Similar companies in Auto & Car Service