Simple Tire's Manufacturer's Warranty Program is Garbage!
I give Simple Tire a 2 because they have a good selection of tires and lower prices. They do ship quickly and the arrangement with local installers is helpful. While I've purchased 16 tires from them and never had to use their manufacturer's warranty, now everything has changed. If you need to use the manufacturer's warranty through Simple Tire, be prepared for massive delays and hassles. I submitted my claim on March 25 with a tire that clearly has a manufacturer's defect. It's now May 11 and I'm still waiting to receive a replacement tire and I've had no indication that one is coming. First, I had to get a local shop to verify the tire is defective. Then I had to send pictures of the defect. Then I had to send the tire back to Simple Tire. Now I'm waiting to see if the manufacturer will replace it after all that hassle. This is the clincher for me. I'll never buy from Simple Tire again. The risk is just too high to warrant the small rewards. You expose yourself to too much risk buying from them. What if all I had was a donut tire instead of an actual spare? I'd be buying a new tire and the manufacturer's warranty would be entirely worthless! Don't do it! Don't take the risk! You may seriously regret it.