I booked a prepaid rental car with Sicily By Car through Rentalcars.com (Booking ref. 615715664). The full payment was taken well in advance. When we arrived at Bergamo Airport within the official 2-hour grace period, I was told there were no cars available. No alternative or assistance was offered, and Rentalcars customer support was equally unhelpful. We were left without the car I had paid for, forced to rent from another company on the spot at a higher price and for fewer days. What followed was almost two months of exhausting correspondence with their support, who replied briefly and dismissively, without ever addressing the key facts. Despite providing clear evidence, they repeatedly denied responsibility. In the end, the only way I recovered my money was by filing a chargeback through my bank for non-delivery of service. This experience caused unnecessary stress, disrupted my vacation plans, and shows that even when you prepay, you may end up with financial, moral, and practical problems during your holiday. Strongly advise avoiding both Rentalcars and Sicily By Car.
Rentalcars.com
1.030 reviews
What reviewers mention
Counted from the words and stars in the reviews below
Reviewers most often mention returns & refunds, prices and delivery. Reviews about returns & refunds and prices are more critical. Based on 30 reviews.
- Returns & refunds13 reviews, average 1.0 out of 5
- Prices11 reviews, average 1.0 out of 5
- Delivery8 reviews, average 1.0 out of 5
- Customer service8 reviews, average 1.0 out of 5
- Communication7 reviews, average 1.0 out of 5
- Parts availability3 reviews, average 1.0 out of 5
1-star reviews30
I rented a car from them last week (August 2025). I paid them for the rental of the car through Hertz. When I picked up the car at Hertz, I was forced to pay them over $200 more for taxes and such. Rental cars.com did NOT save me money! BEWARE! DO NOT USE THEM!!!
I rented a car through them in Colombia. When I arrived to pick it up, the company couldn't release the car to me because I have a passport from one country but a driver's licence from another. There is a mention of having matching ID to pick up the car, but nowhere does it state that that means same country. I've rented all over the world and it has never been a problem before. Alamo was very nice and agreed to waive the cancellation fee that they would normally charge, they put it in writing to Rentalcars.com. Yet Rentalcars refused to return the full amount and made it sound they were doing me a favour by agreeing to refund me part of the rental cost. It took endless emails, first they said I could get the a full refund if Alamo agreed to waive the cancellation fee but they then went back on that and only gave me a partial refund. Terrible customer service. Up until now, I used Rentalcars several times a year, but Never Again! They just steal your money and lie. From now on I rent directly with the rental company.
I will NEVER rent from them again. Their customer service is horrible. Our flight was delayed so my car got canceled and they refused to refund me. I finally got half back but it wasn't my fault that the plane was delayed. They were so mean on the phone and had no care about the customer. Stay away!
Made a reservation thru rentalcars.com with Dollar rental car. Secured a payment with my debit card. I was told at the counter that a debit card was not accepted. So I was not able to rent, but rentalcars.com kept a certain amount of my money and will not refund me my money. I contacted rentalcars.com via chat and was told that debit cards are not accepted as payment. So why can a person make a reservation with a debit card? Better business bureau will be contacted and other agencies to help deal with this issue. DO NOT USE rentalcars.com if you want to rent a car contact a rental car company there are many apps to download. BEWARE
Rentalcars.com took no responsibility for issues with the booking. They tried to find every loophole and did not resolve the issue, it was the rental car company Sixt that actually helped and were very good. The rental cost more than Rentalcars.com said it would and they would not refund the difference I was charged. I will not be using Rentalcars.com again. I opened a complaint with them and the agent kept emailing to say that they were looking at the issue, yet it took a month to come back and basically say contact Sixt. Nothing against the agent, but a very poor experience and I will now always go direct with whichever company is actually hiring me the car. I would recommend not booking with this company. I did to try and save money, but it actually ended up costing me more!
not worth the savings to use this company. Any changes cost yiou and tehy give no refunds should your trip shorten. Only used if you are 100% sure of no changes
IK schrijf dit bericht om jullie aandacht te vestigen op een zeer absurde toestand. Ik heb een wagen gereserveerd vandaag in Toulouse Luchthaven om 12h30, door omstandigheden ben ik 45minuten vroeger toegekomen. Aan de counter van Dollar laten ze mij weten dat de wagen niet vroeger beschikbaar kan gemaakt worden. DE wagen staat hier voor de deur. IK moet letterlijk wachten tot 12h30 om zelf maar aan het papierwerk te beginnen. Ik kan dit niet begrijpen. Als dit een verzekeringskwestie is tot daar aan toe maar zelf niet aan de papieren beginnen dat vind ik toch alles behalve een goede customer experience. Ik zal dus moeten wachten tot 12h30 dan zeker nog 20minuten papieren moeten invullen vooraleer ik hier kan vertrekken. Heel dit process gaat langer duren dan mijn eigenlijke vlucht. Dit is de laatste keer dat ik via jullie platform zal bestellen.
SCAMMED
I rented a car in september 2024, they did not manage to find a suitable car to match my request so I refused the rental. I have called over 20 times and is January 2025. Still haven't received any refund. As a side note, The refund amount it's 30% of the sum paid initially for the rental. STAY AWAY! Also, the price of the insurance is even more then the price of the rental... again, STAY AWAY.
I rented a car in september 2024, they did not manage to find a suitable car to match my request so I refused the rental. I have called over 20 times and is January 2025. Still haven't received any refund. As a side note, The refund amount it's 30% of the sum paid initially for the rental. STAY AWAY !!!! Also, the price of the insurance is even more then the price of the rental... again, STAY AWAY.
About Rentalcars.com
- Category
- Logistics & Rental
- Reviews
- Reviews since , 30 reviews
Work at Rentalcars.com? Tools for this company
Similar companies in Logistics & Rental
- Ravenhill RemovalsVerified company5.0· 61 reviews
- Grays Storage and Removals ltdVerified company5.0· 50 reviews
- Vermeer Verhuizingen V.O.F.5.0· 49 reviews
- NYC Great Movers5.0· 45 reviews
- Directconnectautotransport5.0· 44 reviews