Parts are great but returns are terrible
Unless you have a diagnostics tool to tell you the exact part that is wrong, sometimes you need to buy 2 or three parts to properly diagnose and fix the issue. However, sometimes it is just the last part you buy that fixes the issue. Sometimes it is just an update to the software on the newer appliances, which can only be done with a diagnostic machine (enter trained technician). The problem is when you buy parts that work but do not fix the problem PartSelect will not take them back for a full refund. This is especially true for any electric part, which is generally the type of part you need to get the newer machines working again. If PartSelect would accept returns for a full refund on parts that work but did not fix the problem my review would be a 5 star and I would purchase from them again. However, they refused to take back my part for a full refund and now I refuse to use them again. They made $150 on me but that will be the last of my money they get.
Pushy marketing, high prices
I needed a replacement part for a refrigerator door, ended up buying it on Amazon for half the price of PartSelect. I kept receiving pushy marketing emails every day, even after I clicked Unsubscribe several times:-/
Cheaper Isn't Always Better
The part eventually arrived in good condition, the price was the best I could find (cheaper by $10 with a 15% off coupon), and it fixed my refrigerator issue. My problem with this company is the "your part ships today" and "average delivery time for in-stock parts via standard shipping: 1.8 days" claims. Your part does not ship on the day you place the order, they only create a shipping label. Also, 1.8 days is 43 hours and 12 minutes. I placed my order on Tuesday at 3:09pm and the part wasn't received by USPS until Thursday at 12:30pm. That's 44 hours and 21 minutes making it impossible for my part to be delivered in 1.8 days. This is false advertising, inconvenient, and terrible customer service. I was expecting to repair my refrigerator on Thursday, due to false claims, and instead had to wait until Saturday. Doesn't seem like a big deal, but it is when you have hundreds of dollars of food that is going bad. On top of it, I sent an email expressing my concerns and received absolutely no reply. I will not order from this company again and I suggest you look at other companies that don't artificially inflate their abilities so you have a realistic expectation of when you can perform repairs.
Part didn't fit
Part is a front panel for a GE window air conditioner. It came in a GE box but holes don't line up with the controls on my unit. All I really wanted was the filter cover which isn't available separately. They refunded the purchase price but shipping both ways cost 3/4 of the purchase price, so it was a big waste of money and I still don't have a grill.